Prime Minister Justin Trudeau said Wednesday he's satisfied with the public explanation provided by a top Liberal fundraiser whose name surfaced in leaked documents that provide details on legal, offshore tax havens used by the wealthy.
Trudeau's Conservative and NDP rivals, however, are decidedly less so.
Trudeau, who is in Vietnam for this week's APEC meeting, said he's accepted Stephen Bronfman's response to the so-called "Paradise Papers" that he has never funded nor used offshore trusts, and that all his Canadian trusts have paid all federal taxes on their income.
However, when asked why his close personal friend appeared to still be in his role as a key Liberal fundraiser, the prime minister did not directly answer, nor would he speak Bronfman's name.
"In regards to the specific case you mentioned, we have received assurances that all rules were followed, indeed the same assurances made in the public statement released by the family, and we are satisfied with those assurances," Trudeau told a news conference inside Vietnam's presidential palace.
"We have done much in regards to tax avoidance and tax evasion, including working with international partners.
"But we also recognize there is much more to do and you can rest assured that Canada Revenue Agency will take very seriously its responsibility to go after everyone and anyone involved in tax avoidance and tax evasion."
Tax avoidance measures involving offshore trusts are legal, provided that the trust is genuinely managed offshore and that Canadian taxes are paid on any Canadian contributions. And there may be other legitimate reasons for setting up an offshore account, including if you're a contractor doing work in a particular country.
Still, the questions around Bronfman have given the Liberal government's political foes fresh ammunition to accuse Trudeau of leading an ethically challenged government — and they renewed their attacks Wednesday.
Conservative Leader Andrew Scheer called it "unbelievable" that Trudeau would give Bronfman a clean bill of health so soon after the Canada Revenue Agency had promised to delve more deeply into the murky world of offshore tax havens.
"What kind of message does that send to the Canada Revenue Agency and the people that will be reviewing the file? What kind of message does that send to Canadians?" Scheer asked.
"I think what drives Canadians crazy is when they think there's one set of rules for everyone, and a different set of rules for close friends of Liberal ministers or the prime minister."
NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh also called for more investigation, saying it's critical to understand what happened with the Paradise Papers and why Canada's laws allow the super-rich to avoid paying taxes.
"The prime minister says that he is satisfied with the explanation provided by Mr. Bronfman," Singh said. "The reality is Canadians are not satisfied. Canadians expect a just and fair taxation system ... that ensures the wealthy, the well-connected, the powerful also contribute their fair share."
Scheer said the government needs to allow the CRA to determine whether the problem is structural or enforcement-based, and give those accused of playing fast and loose with the rules a chance to defend their actions.
"For the prime minister, before any of that work is done, to go out and say 'We are satisfied' — I think that's terribly inappropriate."
In his statement, Bronfman said he made a single loan to the trust on an arm's-length, fully commercial basis some 25 years ago that was repaid five months later, a transaction that was fully in compliance with Canadian law.
The name of former Liberal prime minister Jean Chretien also appeared in the 13.4 million leaked documents, in a register of investors in Madagascar Oil. It lists Chretien as having received 100,000 stock options.
In a brief statement of his own, Chretien said Madagascar Oil was a client of Heenan Blaikie, a now-defunct Canadian law firm. As a lawyer with the firm, Chretien said he did some work for Madagascar Oil, but all fees were billed by and paid to the law firm itself.
"I never received any share options and I never had a bank account outside Canada," Chretien said.
"Any news report that suggests I have or ever had or was associated in any way with any offshore account is false."
Comments
This is not just a Liberal problem, it is a Conservative problem as well. Due to human nature this seems to be " weakness " of anyone in power. Whoever is in the position of opposition is always eager to point out the foibles of the party in power regardless of the fact they have or will do it themselves.
Andrew Scheer, this is remote from being merely a "Liberal" problem. Check out your bathroom mirror. In fact, like what I'd guess were many voters, I went to the Liberal side to flee your Conservative big corporation tentacles and anti-science climate change denial.
The Liberals are just a smaller species of oligarch-embracing octopus: species Bronfmanis Bronfmanis. Without proportional representation, this dance of mine choosing the smaller danger will continue to be my fate. A democracy in which my vote can't count is a not a democracy. Will I see one in Canada before I die?