Skip to main content

Quebec's highest court rules woman wearing hijab was entitled to be heard

Rania El-Alloul,
Rania El-Alloul takes part in a news conference in Montreal, on Friday, March 27, 2015. File photo by The Canadian Press/Ryan Remiorz

Support strong Canadian climate journalism for 2025

Help us raise $150,000 by December 31. Can we count on your support?
Goal: $150k
$32k

Quebec's highest court has ruled a woman who was denied justice three years ago after a judge ordered her to remove her hijab was entitled to be heard by the court.

The unanimous judgment rendered today in favour of Rania El-Alloul says the Quebec court dress code does not forbid head scarves if they constitute a sincere religious belief and don't harm the public interest.

In 2015, Judge Eliana Marengo refused to hear a case involving El-Alloul's impounded car because El-Alloul refused to remove her Islamic head scarf in the courtroom.

Marengo told her at the time that decorum was important and, in her opinion, El-Alloul wasn't suitably dressed.

El-Alloul's lawyers had appealed the Quebec Superior Court's 2016 decision refusing to declare that she had the right to be heard by the court despite her attire.

Today's judgment by the Quebec Court of Appeal quashes the original judgment by the trial judge and sets aside the Superior Court judgment that denied relief.

Julius Grey, one of El-Alloul's lawyers, says he's pleased with the ruling that puts both issues to rest.

Comments